Erin Heatherton Career Timeline: From Victoria’s Secret Runway to Hollywood and Beyond

There’s a certain irony in Erin Heatherton’s story. A girl from Skokie, Illinois—basketball player, science-fair kid, just another face in the crowd—ends up towering on a Victoria’s Secret billboard in Times Square.

By 2010, she was a certified Victoria’s Secret Angel, walking the runway in jeweled wings, her face plastered on global campaigns. The dream job, right? Except the dream had cracks. And honestly, her timeline reads like a mirror of Victoria’s Secret itself—dizzying highs, public scrutiny, and then the inevitable reinvention.

She wasn’t just a model. She became shorthand for a cultural moment: the height of the Angel era, when televised fashion shows pulled millions of viewers, when the brand defined what “sexy” looked like in the 2000s. The awards. The gossip. The headlines.

But here’s the twist—her career didn’t stop there. By 2021, Erin had swapped runway glitter for sweat and grit, co-founding Resistance Chicago Lagree, a boutique fitness studio. It felt less about fame, more about authenticity.

Erin Heatherton’s career spans from Victoria’s Secret Angel stardom in 2010 to being a fitness entrepreneur in Chicago by 2021. That arc—small-town discovery, international modeling, Hollywood cameos, public struggles, and reinvention—sets the stage for a story that’s bigger than one person.

From Skokie to South Beach: Early Life & Discovery

How Erin Heatherton Was Discovered at 17

Picture this—Miami’s South Beach, July 2006. Sunburned tourists, neon bikinis, the usual summer chaos. And in the middle of it, a tall 17-year-old from Skokie, Illinois, was just on vacation with friends.

A modeling scout spotted her. Not rehearsed, not staged—literally a walk down Ocean Drive that rewrote her life. One week, you’re playing high school basketball in the Midwest, the next, you’re signing with Marilyn Agency in New York City.

She moved to New York almost immediately. Packed up, left suburban comfort, and stepped into the high-stakes fashion world. It wasn’t the smooth, slow climb most models talk about—it was an elevator ride. Straight up.

Family Roots and Early Influences

Before the runway lights, there was Skokie, Illinois. Not Milan, not Paris—Skokie. Erin Heather Bubley (yes, that’s her full name) grew up in a Jewish household, attending Solomon Schechter Day School before switching to Niles North High School.

She wasn’t exactly living in a fashion spread. She played basketball. Entered science fairs. Spent afternoons like every other Midwestern teen. Honestly, who would expect a science-fair kid to end up strutting for Prada?

That’s the part competitors often skip—the “normal teen” background. But it matters. Because her foundation wasn’t glamour, it was grit. Faith. Community. A suburban gym where she practiced free throws.

To me, it feels like those roots explain her later pivots. When she walked away from Victoria’s Secret, when she leaned into wellness, when she built a studio in Chicago—it wasn’t random. It was her circling back to something more grounded, more her.

Breaking Into Fashion: Runway Debut & Early Modeling

First Runway Walk in 2006: A Defining Moment

Backstage at New York Fashion Week, September 2006—the air thick with hairspray, stylists shouting last calls, and models pacing in borrowed heels. And there she was. Erin Heatherton, barely 17, is about to walk her very first show for Diane von Fürstenberg.

Was she nervous? Of course. She later admitted the chaos felt surreal, like being thrown into a movie you didn’t audition for. Honestly, I can picture it: the music swelling, the lights blinding, and a teenager from Skokie striding out as if she’d been doing this forever.

That debut wasn’t just another walk—it was a door blast. Within months, she was booked for Prada, Chanel, and a carousel of European houses. No gentle ramp-up, no safety net. Straight into the deep end of high fashion.

From Magazines to Global Campaigns

The runway wasn’t enough. Within a year of her 2006 debut, Erin Heatherton’s face was everywhere—literally staring back at you from glossy covers. According to Models.com, she landed Elle Russia (June 2007), GQ Spain (2008), and Harper’s Bazaar Czech Republic (2009).

It wasn’t just covers either. She became the face of H&M, posed for Armani, slipped into campaigns for Lacoste and Diesel. To me, it felt like she was on a carousel that never slowed down—one week Milan, the next a shoot in Paris.

Critics at the time called her look “fresh Midwestern meets high fashion.” Fans just saw her everywhere. The awards? Not really. The headlines? Plenty.

Victoria’s Secret Era: Angel Status & Global Fame

Becoming an Official VS Angel in 2010

Her first walk for Victoria’s Secret came in 2008. By 2010, she wasn’t just walking. She was crowned an official Victoria’s Secret Angel, wings strapped on, part of the elite club that defined beauty for an entire decade.

The glamour was everywhere. Billboards in Times Square. Magazine spreads dripping in pink satin. The “Showstopper” campaign—one of the brand’s splashiest ads—featured her front and center.

Critics at the time called Victoria’s Secret “the Super Bowl of lingerie,” and Erin was suddenly on the main stage. Millions tuned into the annual show, which in those years was more pop concert than fashion.

Why Erin Heatherton Left Victoria’s Secret

Here’s the hard truth: Erin Heatherton left Victoria’s Secret in 2013, citing extreme weight-loss demands that harmed her mental health.

She later told Time and The Independent that before her final two shows, she was pressured to slim down, already lean, yet asked to be smaller. She tried. Diets, overtraining, skipped meals. And it broke her.

“Honestly, I thought I was doing everything right,” she admitted. But the toll was brutal—depression, exhaustion, a body pushed past its limit.

This wasn’t just her struggle. It was the system. The obsession with “perfect” that turned Angels into symbols instead of women. To me, that was the first crack in the glittering façade—the moment the fantasy admitted it was unsustainable.

Beyond the Runway: Hollywood, TV, and Media Cameos

Erin Heatherton’s Movie Roles Explained

After the runway, she tried Hollywood. Not a full leap, more like a test.

In 2013, Erin Heatherton popped up in Grown Ups 2 as Ginger, a brief role in Adam Sandler’s comedy chaos. The film was a box office hit but a critical disaster—7% on Rotten Tomatoes.

Then came She’s Funny That Way in 2014, a quirky Peter Bogdanovich project with Owen Wilson and Jennifer Aniston. Her role was blink-and-miss, but for a model stepping onto a film set, it was a pivot worth noting (Variety).

Television Cameos and Fashion Show Appearances

Her film roles may have been blink-and-miss, but TV gave Erin Heatherton a different kind of spotlight.

In 2013, she popped up on FX’s comedy The League. A year later, she appeared on Million Dollar Contractor (2014), this time as herself. Random? Sure. But it showed she wasn’t boxed into one lane.

And then there were the Victoria’s Secret Fashion Show appearances. Between 2008 and 2013, she was part of the spectacle every December—televised, hyped, half-concert, half-runway. Honestly, those shows were less about lingerie and more about prime-time entertainment.

Setbacks & Resilience: Lawsuits, Bankruptcy & Recovery

The RetroActive Lawsuit & Business Struggles

Here’s the twist—after the wings came the lawsuits.

In 2015, Heatherton tried something different: RetroActive, a sportswear line she co-created with stylist Clare Byrne. On paper, it made sense. Athleisure was exploding.

But the project never launched. By 2016, Byrne filed a $10 million lawsuit, accusing Heatherton of breach of contract (Page Six). The case was later settled out of court, terms undisclosed.

It marked the first time her career collided with the brutal reality of business. No glossy covers. No safety net. Just contracts, lawyers, and a startup dream that fizzled.

Filing for Bankruptcy in 2019: What Went Wrong?

By April 2019, the headlines told a different story. Erin Heatherton filed for bankruptcy, citing more than $560,000 in debt against just $6,500 in assets.

It wasn’t just unpaid credit cards. The Blast reported that filings tied part of the mess to a Chicago condo lawsuit, plus the failed RetroActive venture, and the inconsistent income modeling often brings.

It felt less like a scandal and more like a cautionary tale: the volatility of modeling income, the risk of betting on fame as financial security.

Reinvention in Fitness: Co-Founding Resistance Chicago Lagree

Why Heatherton Chose Fitness Over Fashion

By 2021, Erin Heatherton wasn’t chasing castings anymore—she was co-founding Resistance Chicago Lagree, a boutique fitness studio.

In a 2021 Instagram post later quoted by People, she wrote: “I wanted to be authentic, not a fantasy.” That single line summed up her pivot.

Honestly, I thought this pivot made more sense than another fashion comeback. It wasn’t about relaunching her image. It was about reclaiming health, authenticity, and a different kind of spotlight.

How Her Studio Fits Today’s Wellness Trends

Celebrity pivots into wellness aren’t new. Miranda Kerr launched KORA Organics. Karlie Kloss built Kode with Klossy.

But Erin Heatherton? She chose a different lane. In 2021, she co-founded Resistance Chicago Lagree, doubling down on local impact. No billion-dollar branding—just reformers and resilience.

Resistance Chicago Lagree positioned Heatherton alongside celebrity wellness entrepreneurs, but with a hyper-local, community-driven model.

In September 2025, Heatherton shared clips from her studio on Instagram, showing classes still thriving. In today’s boutique fitness boom, that choice feels less like retreat and more like reinvention.

Love, Relationships & New Beginnings

Dating Leonardo DiCaprio: Headlines & Media Frenzy

For almost a year—from December 2011 to November 2012—Erin Heatherton was linked to Leonardo DiCaprio.

They were spotted biking in New York, vacationing in Mexico, slipping into events where flashbulbs always followed. People covered the romance, but she kept quiet.

Erin Heatherton dated Leonardo DiCaprio from late 2011 until November 2012 (People).

No speculation here. This wasn’t a scandal—just an Angel caught in the celebrity machine.

Marriage to Karol Kocemba in 2023

In March 2022, she announced her engagement to Karol Kocemba on Instagram. By January 17, 2023, the two were married and later covered by People.

Erin Heatherton married Karol Kocemba in January 2023, confirming it on Instagram.

After lawsuits, bankruptcy, and gossip, the wedding felt like her happiest headline—because it wasn’t really a headline at all. It was a life event.

Comparing Career Paths: Erin Heatherton vs Other VS Angels

How Heatherton’s Journey Differs From Peers

The Angel roster was stacked. Adriana Lima stayed until 2018. Alessandra Ambrosio launched a swimwear label. Karlie Kloss built tech programs.

Erin Heatherton? She went home. Built Resistance Chicago Lagree.

Unlike many Angel peers, Heatherton pivoted into boutique fitness instead of global fashion or tech ventures.

Her career wasn’t about scaling influence. It was about scaling back—and that’s what makes her stand out.

What Erin Heatherton’s Story Reveals About the Industry

Her timeline isn’t just about one model. It’s about the fashion industry pressures that demanded thinness, perfection, and silence.

Her candid 2013 exit exposed the cracks. Her 2019 bankruptcy showed the volatility of modeling income. Her 2021 studio? Proof of resilience.

Erin Heatherton’s career arc underscores the instability of modeling, but also the power of reinvention.

Fashion historian Valerie Steele once noted the Angel era “sold a fantasy that wasn’t built to last.” Heatherton’s story is living proof.

Erin Heatherton’s Career Legacy

Looking back, Erin Heatherton’s timeline doesn’t read like a straight runway—it zigzags. From South Beach discovery at 17 to the glitter of Victoria’s Secret Angel status, from Hollywood detours to bankruptcy court, her arc is one of disruption.

She was part of a cultural era—the Angels—that shaped beauty standards worldwide. But she also became a voice against those standards, opening the door to conversations about body image, mental health, and authenticity.

Erin Heatherton’s legacy is resilience and reinvention, pivoting from modeling to fitness entrepreneurship in 2021.

Some fans remember the jeweled wings. Others, the bankruptcy headlines. To me, the more interesting story is the comeback—choosing sweat over sparkle, stability over spectacle.

Her story proves that reinvention is possible, even when the world has already written your ending.

Frequently Asked Questions